Let me simplify this for you Loomis, since you are seeming to have some difficulty comprehending what I have been saying:
I know this is going to really blow your mind. The smoking ban, only extends to less than 15 events. (no sh1t) So if you want to throw around your statistics about smokers numbers on the incline or decline, or the amount of money the industry makes, etc. You are wasting your time. There is ONLY one issue with the smoking rule and that is... SMOKERS CAN'T SMOKE DURING PDGA EVENTS!. That's it...

Really??? wow!! Maybe you need to actually READ my first post and then THINK about it. I stated in the beginning that it only applied to MAJOR EVENTS!!! Not PDGA events....only MAJOR events. This does not include NT, A Tier, B Tier, C Tier, or any other level of event. I can smoke all I want under the current rules at these events (all of this was acknowledged in my first post as well).
Dale - My point is this: If you want to throw around your weight as a smoking disc golfer, do so. Otherwise, it does nothing for anyone to listen to moot, peripheral arguments. You didn't come up with any valid points to discuss other than the ones I addressed. You were the one who raised personal issues with your money, involvement, etc. None of which are issues worth discussing. The only issue you have is "to smoke, or not to smoke" and that is answered simply by saying, "smoke if you want, but not during PDGA events." That's it. Smoking looks bad, period. It hinders the growth of the "professional" side of the sport.
Who's throwing weight around? In my initial rebuttal (which, as stated in the post, was partially hypothetical) of your statement regarding sponsorship money that would only be possible if smoking was banned as well as my subsequent ones, I was simply pointing out that smokers make up a sizable portion of the dues-paying PDGA membership and the PDGA could POTENTIALLY lose ground financially if the sponsorships aren't large enough.
Never said to quit. Never said it at all. In fact, since this debate started (in another thread many moons ago) I have stated emphatically that I don't care if you do. However, I have made it very clear that if the rules say you can't smoke, then you can't smoke. I have also stated, that if you want to see the sport grow (outside of the realm of just a leisure sport) then you have to change the image. Because, as I have said over and over again, it's all about the presentation. The smokers on the boards, have brought up the fringe issue of "rights" or "we are the sport" or the rest of the endless babble of nonsense. It's a non-issue. It's a smoker's gripe that exists everywhere. It's always the smokers who feel "hunted" and "overlooked" in this issue and it has nothing to do with that at all.
Really? Are you that stringent on ALL PDGA rules, or only the ones YOU want to enforce. I have now played in only 3 or 4 PDGA tournaments, but have seen so many rule violations (varying from clothing to drinking to scoring) at EVERY tournament, it is mind numbing. Many of these violations I have simply ignored, I confess, which isnt the way it should be but is (especially Jack's favorite - the proper shirt which even TD's refuse to address). I would suggest that before you attempt to add additional rules for the "presentation" factor of the sport, you figure out how to enforce the ones already in place. And you never told me not to play?
This isn't about you and me, if it was, the list of what you could or couldn't do at a disc golf event would be vastly different. You just seem to think smoking is somehow integral to the livelihood of the sport. This is a common belief among smokers. I would challenge you to organize your fellow smokers and walk away from the events. Get a hold of Feldberg and Climo and start a movement. I'm sure those two are willing to walk away from disc golf. In fact, walk away from the sport altogether. Take your butts and go play ball golf.
Sounds to me like you are telling me that I shouldnt play.
I'm barely tolerable in person for most people. And it could be because I'm very outspoken and I am going to remain so. I was silent for a long time about my attitudes about disc golf, but not anymore. I have a vested interest in this sport and I'm not going to sit idly by and watch it be ripped apart by infighting foolishness. I don't know Dale or "A" and I even offered to light your cigarette, so I hardly see how that is me trying to "exclude" you from the sport. I don't give two sh1ts about either of you, UNTIL you get in my way. And if you want to smoke at a PDGA event, well that's getting in my way.
Before this thread, I would have disagreed based on your seemingly knowledgable, very descriptive, and entertaining posts. Now, not only would I agree, but would add "on line" as well as "in person". Maybe that is because I, too, am very outspoken.
What "vested interest" could you possibly have? A vested interest implies that you are owed somthing for your previous contributions. I dont know what you have done in the past other than play (and could care less), but regardless of what you have or havent done you are owed nothing from the PDGA and disc golf. Since you are in college, you certainly have not been playing much longer than I have, although you HAVE been playing competitively much longer than me. BIG DEAL!! All I can see that you have invested is time and tournaments, which is no more than my "vested" interest.