Part of the problem I think was that the tags had to be purchased and there was zero chance of any return. Bragging rights only.
That's too bad, I'd say the return is getting the club a little extra money.
I believe the cost of getting the tags is pretty minimal. Could be another recruiting tool for the club. KCFDC could spring for them and issue to all active members.
"Hey, wheredya git that? How can I get one?"
Pay out or not, it would not cost the tag holders. A small perk for joining and might lead to a few new memebers.
Another thing to do is add, the cost of the tag's to membership ie $5, or $10 and if the club pockets a few bucks off it, then good.
I would personally like to see it come back next year, and this forum would be the perfect place to set up matches and stuff.