Well said, Hyzer.
Frankly, if I leave a disc behind for whatever reason, whether or not I'm allowed/not-allowed to retrieve it...I don't expect to ever see it again. C'est la vie.
Can only think of one disc in my bag that I might shed a tear = a '98 Roc that I have absolutely no replacement for...none in my bag or archives are even close to being as understable.
This whole debacle revolves around trespassing...into a body of water w/o the P&R's permission.