My daughters are younger. I used to give them old drivers, but they really did not like them that well. I think the key is, a disc that will stay in the air longer. I gave my 8 year old a putter and she loved it! Of course I told her every shot that was straight was a great shot. Your daughter is older and can probably handle some real drivers. I would stay light, like even 150 class. Flippy discs work well for starters (XL, Stratus, Pro TeeBird, Leopard, etc.) You might even try the Sidewinder. Also, there are some discs that are for beginners, although I have seen pro's using them. i.e. Express (LRD), and Shark (mid.). Buy her a new disc, after all, she is a teen, and let her pick the color! These things really matter to some young ladies (and gentlemen too). Good Luck!