2013 Rosedale Open C Tier Kansas City, KS - March 10th

[dan howard]

If it were only that easy Tom.  My sister is in town this weekend, we'll be tearing it up Saturday night.  Starting at Free State to watch the Hawks @ 5, feel free to join us after KanU.

[TPalmer]

Thanks for the offer Dan but I don't think I'll be doing any drinking the night before the Rosey Open.  Gotta fit in that extra hour somewhere.   

[Skyhawkmd]

I just played Rosie for the first time since the snow and was surprised that the tee pads aren't all clear with all the traffic that course has got since the snow, if I would have known I would have cleared them.

[asjzn6]

Saw that Rosedale open had 84, wyco 88, frost breaker 86, pretty good numbers scott looking forward to what else you can bring to the KC area

[coops]

Good weekend Scott! Maybe next time order some better weather, though.

[coops]

Did the first and second round get combined for purposes of round ratings?

That second round played way harder with the wind picking up and the temperature dropping.

[TPalmer]

Did the first and second round get combined for purposes of round ratings?

That second round played way harder with the wind picking up and the temperature dropping.

I wondered the same.  I shot one stroke worse the second round and my rating for the second round was higher than the first.

[DDKC Scott Reek]

When I enter scores in, I'm only selection course layout, not conditions.  When I submit the official report I will mention those conditions, not sure what that changes though

[hberciunas]

Nice weekend Scott . . . DD  . . . and all those who put in the hours and work. Fun gathering at the store after.

No more from DDKC till May 18 . . . SMITHVILLE!!!!! wooot!!
2 rounds? 3? 4?

[DDKC Scott Reek]

There will be a one rounder or two before then

[dickthediscparker]

When I enter scores in, I'm only selection course layout, not conditions.  When I submit the official report I will mention those conditions, not sure what that changes though

As far as I know, the weather has nothing to do with the ratings.

[coops]

When I enter scores in, I'm only selection course layout, not conditions.  When I submit the official report I will mention those conditions, not sure what that changes though

Yeah, it just seemed like the ratings were a smidge low that second round. My 53 felt way better than a mid-950s. And, on top of that, there weren't any 1000s in the second round, which is strange enough on its own.

[coops]

When I enter scores in, I'm only selection course layout, not conditions.  When I submit the official report I will mention those conditions, not sure what that changes though

As far as I know, the weather has nothing to do with the ratings.

Weather certainly does affect ratings. It changes how people shoot and what scores get what ratings. The other thing too is that the PDGA likes to combine rounds in similar conditions as long as they are on the same set up. Yesterday, though played on the same set up, couldn't have been any different. The morning was mild and calm, and the afternoon was blustery and windy. I would venture to say that it got 4-5 strokes harder between rounds.

[jack]

When I enter scores in, I'm only selection course layout, not conditions.  When I submit the official report I will mention those conditions, not sure what that changes though

As far as I know, the weather has nothing to do with the ratings.

Correct, the only thing that matters on the ratings is the other players rating playing.  If the others playing have a high score, the ratings are adjusted accordingly.  So if a 1000 rated player shot 48 for a 1000 the first round and then they shot 52 for a 1000 the second round, it is based off of all the other players with PDGA ratings.  It will self adjust slightly as it becomes official though.

So though weather doesn't change, the PDGA also doesn't "manufacture" ratings based on the weather and alter them.  It is based solely on a mathematical formula.  THe harder the course is scored by the people with ratings already the harder the ratings will be.  If 4 1000 rated players all shoot that 48=1000 in round one, and then shoot 52 in the afternoon, everything will be skewed by four strokes on the afternoon round.  So the weather plays a part only by the score from the players playing.  It doesn't change the ratings criteria because it rained, or because they have another event that was used earlier. 

Think about it in KC, we have one of the few places in the world where we have 3-5 placements on every freaking hole.  Based on that how would the PDGA be able to determine each hole specific to each course, unless we as TD's turned in each location......it doesn't happen.....

Weather only affects the ratings because it affects the entire field's score.  It is with that notion that weather affects the ratings, but not altering the ratings based on the weather.....

[Utz]

All scores thrown on the same course layout in multiple rounds will be used to determine the SSA and ratings for that layout except when wind is significantly different

So it looks like the SSA is still being calculated from the first round, which would be the 49 (1000 rated.) It looks like each throw is then worth 10 ratings points.

The second round gets a little tricky. Because there wasn't a Scratch Score, and the general low scores of the field, we see compressed ratings. For instance, a 51 in the second round rated higer (4 points) than a 50 in the first round.

I'm not sure what formula they apply to appease the "except when the wind is significantly different" scenario in the above PDGA statement. But I reckon these ratings will be recalculated before everything is said and done.